29 October 2026
The Hon. R.A. SIMMS (16:51): I thank members for their contributions: the Hon. Russell Wortley—who stunned me with the about-face that he delivered on behalf of the Labor government—the Hon. Ben Hood, the Hon. Sarah Game and the Hon. Carlos Quaremba. The Hon. Mr Quaremba referenced the Labor Party's own bill back when they were in opposition in 2021, and I think it is worth noting there are no original ideas in politics. I have always been a big fan of recycling, and in crafting this particular bill I drew on the inspiration of a bill that Labor introduced when they were in opposition, which, as the honourable member identified, proposed almost identical mechanisms.
We have heard the speech from the Hon. Russell Wortley today, but I think it might be instructive to hear what Labor had to say when they introduced a similar bill back in 2021. I will read some excerpts from the Hon. Stephen Mullighan because, might I say, what he had to say resonated with me at the time. Indeed, the Greens introduced amendments in this place, which were supported by the Labor opposition. What he said then still holds true today. Let's revisit some of his reflections. When he introduced that bill he said, and I quote:
…this is a most important and urgent piece of proposed legislation. It seeks to ensure the functions of government can continue while placing a necessary and appropriate constraint on some of the excesses which have become the hallmark of the Liberal government in South Australia.
The Liberal government was who he was admonishing at the time. He went on to say:
…the government will publish, at excessive taxpayer costs, advertisements across television media, radio media, newspaper media, social media and other online platforms to try to bolster its political stocks.
This is what he was saying in the lead-up to an election. He continued:
If a political party wants to do that, or if a political candidate wants to do that, of course they are free to do that within the appropriate strictures of our electoral laws, but it should not be done…at taxpayers' expense.
He goes on to say:
This bill introduces some necessary and, I think we can say, overdue strictures when it comes to government advertising, particularly in the current context when the government is looking at trying to bolster its political stocks at taxpayers' expense. Effectively, what this regime will mean is that there is now an independent arbiter for when taxpayer-funded advertising is to occur, and that independent arbiter will be the Auditor-General under the auspices of the Public Finance and Audit Act…
It will be up to a statutory officer, an independent officer, appointed by the parliament to reach a judgement about whether it is absolutely necessary for the functions of government. If it is not necessary for the functions of government, then it will not be approved. I think that is wholly appropriate, because as we have seen, we have—
again, he goes on to criticise the Liberal Party—
a Liberal Party that has become accustomed to the habit of using taxpayer resources and using taxpayer systems and infrastructure to try to bolster its own stocks.
He goes on to say:
My comments, of course, were to exemplify how, similar to the use of taxpayers' money, this government has become accustomed to using taxpayer resources for its own naked political interests. That is something that this parliament should guard against, and that is what this bill does.
He goes on to say:
We bring this bill to this place with the intention of refocusing this government and future governments on spending taxpayers' money on advertising where it should be, and that is in promoting the proper functions of government in the public interest, not promoting the flagging political fortunes of the South Australian Liberal Party. I commend the bill to all those in the house.
How times change because this was Labor's position back in 2021 and then, just five years later, they deploy the Hon. Russell Wortley to deliver very underwhelming opposition to the bill, and that is because they know they do not have a leg to stand on because they have been exposed as pure hypocrites when it comes to this matter. They were very happy when they were in opposition to push for maximum transparency when the shoe was on the other foot. They were very happy to admonish the Liberal Party when they were in government and say that they were wasting taxpayer funds.
And, indeed, the core critique of the Hon. Stephen Mullighan in his second reading speech was that the Marshall government was spending too much money on advertising. Wow! If only one had a crystal ball at that time because, whilst the Marshall government were big spenders, they certainly did not spend $200 million in four years, and to be fair to the Marshall government, they did have a pandemic to manage during that time in terms of running significant public health campaigns.
So this is pure Labor hypocrisy, and for the second sitting week in a row this chamber is set to pass a bill that Labor supported when they were in opposition. So what does this say about the Labor Party when they are in government? Do not listen to what comes out of their mouths, look at what they do with their feet, look at how they vote. They say one thing when they are in opposition; they do something very different when they are in government.
It is very, very disappointing and I urge the Labor Party—if this bill passes the upper house—to rein in this excessive advertising spending, which I think is a slap in the face to South Australians who are struggling in the middle of a cost-of-living crisis, and to back in the transparency measures that they sought to apply to others. I think that is a pretty reasonable ask. I commend the bill.
Bill read a second time.