Skip navigation

Motion: Community Says No to MotoGP

28 October, 2026

The Hon. R.A. SIMMS (17:13): I move:

That this council—

1. Notes that on 8 October 2026, a community forum was held at the Unley Town Hall on the topic of the MotoGP to hear from the local community, and that:

(a) The event had over 250 registrations and approximately 200 people attended the forum in person and was followed up with a community survey;

(b) The key themes that emerged from the community consultation included:

(i) Strong concern about the loss of mature trees and wildlife habitat;

(ii) Calls for greater transparency regarding costs, contracts and economic benefits;

(iii) Concerns regarding inadequate community consultation;

(iv) Frequent questions about why The Bend Motorsport Park was not selected as an alternative location;

(v) Concerns about the long-term impact on heritage values, biodiversity, urban cooling and public access to the Park Lands.

2. Acknowledges the results of the community survey undertaken on the MotoGP which found that of the 422 survey responses received:

(a) 95% of respondents opposed the proposed MotoGP at Victoria Park;

(b) The Park Lands are primarily used for environmental and wildlife activities (44%), walking (29%), and as local open space (27%);

(c) The dominant concern was the removal of trees and damage to the Park Lands (50%), followed by broader environmental impacts (21%);

(d) There was overwhelming support for stronger protections, with 97% supporting State Heritage listing and 92% supporting World Heritage listing.

3. Calls on the Government to recognise the Adelaide Park Lands as a significant environmental, recreational and heritage asset; and

4. Calls on the Government to release all project costs and environmental assessments relating to the MotoGP, undertake genuine community consultation, investigate alternative locations, and strengthen protections for the Adelaide Park Lands.

The motion that I am moving today notes that on 8 October a community forum was held at the Unley Town Hall on the topic of the MotoGP to hear from the community. It goes on to recognise the nature of the event and some of the feedback, which I intend to share with you today.

My office organised this community meeting because the government's consultation in relation to the MotoGP was so woefully inadequate. The government, when they announced their plans for this project, offered the community just three weeks to have their say. The nature of the consultation was so limited that members of the community were simply being asked to choose between different design options; they were not being given the opportunity to reflect on their overall view on whether or not the MotoGP should proceed.

So, as an elected member of this chamber, I decided it would be appropriate to hold a forum where we would get an opportunity to hear from members of the community directly. Approximately 200 people attended the forum and there were 250 registrations. We also conducted a survey online: 422 survey responses were received, and 95 per cent of respondents opposed the proposed MotoGP at Victoria Park. We asked respondents to identify what benefits the Parklands bring to their lives: 44 per cent noted that the Parklands are primarily used for environmental and wildlife activities; 29 per cent use the Parklands for walking; and 27 per cent recognise them as local open space. There was overwhelming support for stronger protections: 97 per cent supported State Heritage listing and 92 per cent supported World Heritage listing.

In terms of some of the key themes coming out of the survey, there was strong opposition to removing mature trees and damaging wildlife habitat, biodiversity and endangered grasslands. There were serious concerns that permanent bitumen and loss of canopy would increase urban heat and irreversibly change the Parklands. There were concerns around lack of consultation, transparency and independent environmental assessment. There were calls for full project costings and an independent cost-benefit analysis, including ongoing and remediation costs. We know, of course, that the Labor government never did a cost-benefit analysis of the North Adelaide Golf Course, and they have refused to release the cost-benefit analysis for the MotoGP, if indeed one exists.

There was also frequent questioning of why the race cannot be held at Tailem Bend or remain at Phillip Island, and there were concerns about traffic, road closure, noise, pollution, emergency access and disruption to residents and businesses. It was very clear from the feedback that we received from the survey that the Parklands are viewed as public heritage, not land for commercial development. And there was strong concern that replacement saplings cannot replicate mature trees within a meaningful timeframe.

We also got some very useful feedback from the public meeting. In particular, there was strong concern about the loss of mature trees and wildlife habitat. There were calls from members present for greater transparency regarding costs, contract and economic benefits—again, very similar to the feedback we got from the survey. There was concern around inadequate community consultation and also concerns about long-term heritage and the impacts around that.

I thought it might be useful to also share some quotes from the survey. This is feedback direct from the community that I want to share with the parliament. As one person remarked:

My biggest question is: why are we being asked to accept the project before we can properly assess its full costs, impacts and alternatives? And what evidence shows that the lasting public benefit justifies the lasting change to the Parklands?

Good question. Another says:

There's an enormous difference between using the Adelaide Parklands for motorsports and permanently changing the Adelaide Parklands to suit the tenant. I fear that distinction is being lost.

Indeed. Another said, 'People are not against the race per se; they strongly oppose its location in the Parklands.' Indeed, it has been a theme of the Malinauskas government's response to opposition to this project that anytime anyone raises a legitimate concern around the location or the environmental impact, they are met with this mantra that, 'Oh, you must be anti event.' Well, most world-class cities can have public green space and world-class events. We do not have to choose; we can do both. As noted by another respondent to the survey:

The project has a limited life cycle. The tree removal will take multiple MotoGP life cycles to restore. Think long term, not short term!

Another commented about the trees:

Older trees do not equate to multiple newer saplings. You can't chop one and substitute. It has severe and costly ecological effects.

Indeed, we know that replacing a mature tree with a small sapling just does not cut it. Someone else asked:

What happens when the race is over, and we are left with hot road instead of our beautiful parklands?

Another respondent says:

The public should be properly surveyed once all the information as been given outlining environmental impact, cost, habitat impact.

Another notes:

The parklands are a gift from our ancestors—we hold them for the next generation.

Another respondent stated:

The Parklands are supposedly heritage-listed, so how is it possible the Government can simply take vast sections and completely change the topography, surface, and ignore Light's Vision and the uniqueness of Adelaide and its Parklands, which is something other cities around the world are trying to replicate.

Another respondent asks:

What is wrong with putting Tailem Bend on the map? Huge space for the event and opportunity for growth on many fronts.

I agree with the concerns that were expressed by these residents. It is a pretty sad state of affairs when, rather than being able to provide feedback through a genuine consultation process, members of the community are required to send this feedback via a crossbench member of parliament. What does this say about the government's consultation process? It is a sham; it is a joke. We know that this government does not give a stuff about what people think about this issue. They have made that very clear from the outset because the Premier has said that, whatever the community says, he is going ahead with this regardless. It is treating the people of this state with total contempt.

The other part of this motion, 'Calls on the government to recognise the Adelaide Parklands as a significant environmental, recreational and heritage asset' and, indeed, I note that my bill to add the Adelaide Parklands to the State Heritage Register passed the upper house last sitting. But, of course, it is languishing now in the lower house as there is no political will from the Malinauskas government to make good on the election commitment that they made back in 2022. They were very happy to support it when they were in opposition, but since they have got into government, they have backed down. The motion also:

Calls on the government to release all project costs and environmental assessments relating to the MotoGP, undertake genuine…consultation, investigate alternative locations, and strengthen protections for the Adelaide Park Lands.

I recognise the work of my staff in organising the community meeting and I do want to thank all the members of the community that attended. It was a really worthwhile exercise from my perspective. We had lots of useful information that was shared and the survey also provided an opportunity for members of the community to have input who could not attend on the day.

From a Greens' perspective, we intend to continue to go out into the community and amplify the community's voices in this space because we recognise that when we are talking about public open green space, the community's voices must be heard. The Malinauskas government is not going to silence the community on this, and they certainly will not be silencing the Greens either.

Debate adjourned on motion of Hon. I.K. Hunter.